Forest & Bird » Marine and Coastal

Hoki quota increased too soon

(7 posts)
  • Started 2 years ago

Tags:

, ,

  1. Kirstie
    User Profile

    As part of a suite of todays announcements by the Minister of Fisheries, the hoki fishery has been awarded a 20,000 tonne increase in the allowable catch:

    http://www.beehive.govt.nz/release/healthier+stocks+lead+hoki+increase

    As many of you know, Forest & Bird has strongly opposed the green certification tick of hoki under the international 'Marine Stewardship Council'. Our reasons being:

    - The bycatch of hundreds of NZ fur seals, albatrosses and petrels each year;

    - The bycatch of globally threatened basking sharks;

    - When bottom trawling, the fishery has significant impacts on the seafloor, altering seabed communities;

    - The slow response to past stock declines so that large quota cuts;

    - The prevelence of illegal mis-reporting of catches;

    - The catches of small fish on the Chatham Rise and on the West Coast and

    - The lack of a management plan.

    As such, hoki is listed as one of the worst seafood choices on our Best Fish Guide.

    Quotas are this year being increased on the basis of one year’s good recruitment, following several years of poor recruitment. Scientists say for the once depleted West coast stock that the stock is as likely to be withing target range as it is to be below it. In other words, there is still considerable uncertainty.

    Leaping straight in and increasing the quota by 20,000t is as far from a precautionary approach as you can get.

    We are disappointed to say the least.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  2. Quentin
    User Profile

    Here's what Green Co-Leader Metiria Turei said in a statement: http://www.greens.org.nz/press-releases/hoki-quota-increase-under-international-spotlight

    Posted 2 years ago #
  3. Kirstie
    User Profile

    This is why the decision is just plain ol irresponsible and as far from the precuationary approach as you can get.....

    Below are what's called 'snail diagrams' for the western hoki stock (two different model runs). It tracks the change in the abundance of fish in the stock, from lots of fish (far right of scale) to no fish (far left of scale).

    It shows depletion of the hoki stock from first the records in 1972 (red square) to current estimated abundance (last dot in the chain).

    The top graph (model run 1.1) shows the stock to be just within safe limits, though the text in the plenary states "About as likely as not (40-60% probability) to be above the lower end of the Interim Management Target". The bottom graph (model run 1.2) is more optimistic.

    The new quota is just above 2004 quota levels - a time when hoki were in their worst, most depleted state.

    Attachments

    1. Snail_graphs_WesternStock_2009_assessm.jpg (81.2 KB, 0 downloads) 2 years old
    Posted 2 years ago #
  4. Kirstie
    User Profile

    There was an even easier to follow graph in today's Dom Post (Web 30th Sept)- front page of Business Section.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  5. If more consumers understood the appalling bycatch and bottom trawling by hoki fishing boats, I'm certain they would reject hoki in favour of more sustainably caught fish.
    Forest & Bird's Best Fish Guide is one good way to spread the message about thinking before you buy.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  6. The Government must surely be giving into the commercial industries wishes here. When is the Government going to consider the wider ocean ecology and consider what else the Hoki fishery feeds and the damage such a huge removal causes to those species and the associated systems.

    The loss of basking sharks, seals, albatrosses and petrels surely must be considered unacceptable. Basking sharks are becoming very rare and New Zealand stands by while commercial interests take precedence over preservation of species.

    An increase in Hoki production now simply indicates the willingness of this Government to ignore environmental issues where they can be hidden under the ocean.

    I encourage the Minister to publich the stock records of Hoki to the wider scientific community and media and justify the increases on the world stage.

    Posted 2 years ago #
  7. auckland anne
    User Profile

    There's something terribly disturbing and totally undignified, even childish, about the speed with which some of these current govt politicians appear to be unceremoniously dismantling as many environmental safety-nets as they can lay their hands on at the moment...like watching kids in a candy shop....and what's really insulting is the way it's all being justified because it is "economically sensible", or "conservation economics" for want of a better description...

    Posted 2 years ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.